Harris T. Fudpucker wrote:
The pond in the back of the house has lots of bass, and yesterday I went out for a few minutes. Within three cast, I had my first fish, a 1 1/2# lm. I unhooked and threw him back. A few more cast and I had a 2# bass. I unhooked the fish from one of the trebles, and he started jumping around. Before I could do anything, the second set of trebles hooked him in the gills, bleeding but unhooked I slipped him back into the water. Do you think he will live?
No one really has much insight after the fish is released unless they have a tagging or other system to track. I have caught a few fish with torn gills that were obviously not working (a dead white gill is pretty obvious). So it is clear to me that they can survive some level of gill damage.
One thing is for certain...if you didn't release it, it would have been certain death.