fishyaker222kamp wrote:
It may all come down to your budget and how often you plan to use it. My suggestion would be to aim for a St. Croix rod, and a "large arbor" styled fly reel to go with it. Depending on your fishing habitat...streams vs. rivers/streams, something in a 5 weight would easily handle trout up to the 24" range. Open water is nice because a fish can run anywhere. Rivers get tricky if your fish can get back into their log jam lairs, etc. so that is when a heavier rod might be wise.
A 9' length would be a good place to start as well. Over the years, like many fisherman will confess, you tend to accumulate a lot of gear. I won't say how many, but I own rods from just about every manufacture out there and in terms of performance...they are basically all the same. I like to look for good deals on used tackle, so that might be worthy of your consideration as well.
Fiberglass, graphite, split cane bamboo, and other exotics all have a different action. For my general fly fishing, a graphite St Croix Legend in a 9' 5 WT is my all around "go to" rig. Honestly, a lot of times it can boil down to appearances...that is to say...the rod blank color, reel seat (wood or synthetic), line guide style, thread color whippings, etc. This may sound strange, but if I like the aesthetics of the rod/reel I am using, it adds to my enjoyment of the outing. I am not looking to impress anybody...it's just a mental thing! For instance, I like to golf...and my favorite set of driving clubs are made of persimmon wood, purchased decades ago after high school. Sure, I do have a couple of the modern "jumbos", but frankly I'd rather lose some distance and use a more traditional club! My golfing buddies think I'm crazy, but we all still end up with the same scores.
Good luck on your research and ultimate choice!
It may all come down to your budget and how often ... (
show quote)
Beautiful fish and beautiful clubs...your advise is right on the money. Marsh