Fishing Stage - Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
Would you report several rod/bag/method limit violations to parks and wildlife?
Page <<first <prev 4 of 6 next> last>>
Dec 9, 2019 16:54:32   #
scroller
 
New York Niagara river bank ( upper)

Reply
Dec 9, 2019 17:12:44   #
plumbob Loc: New Windsor Maryland
 
BongsonBob wrote:
To Plumbob; East Bay in the San Francisco Bay area


Thanks BB. Know your area from many of business trips out there in the past. If the Prime Rib restaurant is still in Business I believe it was on Van Ness St that was my favorite spot in all of SF. But you can keep those hills.

Reply
Dec 9, 2019 17:40:15   #
3mlthoma Loc: Cape Coral
 
Funny you mentioned picking up trash l did the same thing yesterday, l have lost access to many places because of trash.
Yes l would report them but it is very hard for the Fish and Game people to get an conviction. They have to catch them in the “act”.
I did find a gill net once when l was wading fishing here in Fl so l called and they did go out and got. The FWR agent actually called me to let me that they got the net out of the water

Reply
 
 
Dec 9, 2019 17:44:00   #
EasternOZ Loc: Kansas City Metro
 
MLT welcome to the forum.

Reply
Dec 9, 2019 18:12:24   #
Big A Loc: Mesa, Arizona
 
EasternOZ wrote:
Inconspicuously take pictures?


Just try not to be blatant about it ! Either do it quietly/stealthily while they're pre-occupied or pretend to do 'selfies', and catch them in the background ! Shouldn't be too difficult with the phone cameras out there nowadays !

Reply
Dec 9, 2019 18:46:34   #
badboyattitude Loc: Palm Bay Florida
 
In Florida it's $340 for a small fish. Out of season snook is like $750. Turn them bitches in. Plus here you can get an award,$.

Reply
Dec 9, 2019 18:49:58   #
BobbyJ Loc: Texas
 
FS Digest wrote:
I typically fish in a different neighborhood for each species, so I get around. I have one for gar, one for carp (my gar hood is militantly opposed to non-residents fishing there because that lake is full of footballs, but they let me fish because I take their trash), one for bass, catfish, etc. I run into other fishermen all the time, and aside from a small kid wanting to keep their first fish that's too small, I haven't seen much of anything illegal beyond putting tilapia back, which I admittedly do occasionally.

The first trout stocking happened the day before Thanksgiving, so I've been chasing them almost exclusively at the public park lake. I've been 5 or 6 times since, for only an hour or 2 each time, but EVERY time, I've seen SOMETHING illegal. It's a highly pressured pond, not bigger than 2 acres, and it's pretty standard for there to be 3-5 other guys fishing, mostly for catfish. People fish with 3 or 4 rods (2 rod limit), take more than the limit, and today I saw 2 guys using a casting net. On top of all that, I've spent at least 15 minutes cleaning up trash/discarded line 20 feet from trashcans all but one time, and that's because I was last to leave in the evening and the first there in morning, as I felt like soaking a line before work.

Would you make the call? Given how many disregard regulations and how freely they discuss their violations, I tend to doubt whether or not many of these guys are even licensed.

Several of them are clearly feeding their families, which is where I pause.

What say you?

--
by mypostingname13
I typically fish in a different neighborhood for e... (show quote)



No, I wouldn’t. I would kindly tell them about the law, but after that, I would go no further. I sort of understand that some will; it’s that I have inadvertently broken the law like that before. Throwing dead fish back serves no purpose in my opinion. Education is about as far as I would take it.

Reply
 
 
Dec 9, 2019 20:50:57   #
Big A Loc: Mesa, Arizona
 
Trouble with trying to educate some people is that they're either
too dense for any of it to sink in,
or they probably just don't give a crap ! If you run into one with a bad attitude, bad temper and a firearm, you'll soon see WHY you let the 'legal beagles' sniff out the problem and keep a safe
distance !

Reply
Dec 9, 2019 21:41:43   #
The Old Man Loc: Oregon
 
I try to always turn them in. Once I turned in one guy of three who I saw land a salmon take it to his car and put it in his trunk without tagging it. The next time I was volunteering at the fish hatchery I heard one of the employees telling someone that the State police ended up ticketing one for a salmon he did not tag one for no salmon tag and one for no fishing license. They are poachers turn them in.

Reply
Dec 9, 2019 21:56:09   #
EasternOZ Loc: Kansas City Metro
 
TOM

Welcome to the forum.

Reply
Dec 9, 2019 22:16:45   #
20mules Loc: Chesaw, Washington
 
FS Digest wrote:
I typically fish in a different neighborhood for each species, so I get around. I have one for gar, one for carp (my gar hood is militantly opposed to non-residents fishing there because that lake is full of footballs, but they let me fish because I take their trash), one for bass, catfish, etc. I run into other fishermen all the time, and aside from a small kid wanting to keep their first fish that's too small, I haven't seen much of anything illegal beyond putting tilapia back, which I admittedly do occasionally.

The first trout stocking happened the day before Thanksgiving, so I've been chasing them almost exclusively at the public park lake. I've been 5 or 6 times since, for only an hour or 2 each time, but EVERY time, I've seen SOMETHING illegal. It's a highly pressured pond, not bigger than 2 acres, and it's pretty standard for there to be 3-5 other guys fishing, mostly for catfish. People fish with 3 or 4 rods (2 rod limit), take more than the limit, and today I saw 2 guys using a casting net. On top of all that, I've spent at least 15 minutes cleaning up trash/discarded line 20 feet from trashcans all but one time, and that's because I was last to leave in the evening and the first there in morning, as I felt like soaking a line before work.

Would you make the call? Given how many disregard regulations and how freely they discuss their violations, I tend to doubt whether or not many of these guys are even licensed.

Several of them are clearly feeding their families, which is where I pause.

What say you?

--
by mypostingname13
I typically fish in a different neighborhood for e... (show quote)
Think about it for a minute. You are only there for a hour or two at a time and this is what you see in that period. How many violations do you guess are happening that you do not see? Multiply what you see by any number you pick and imagine what will happen to that fishery in very short order. Do your part to protect your fishing and call fish and game.

Reply
 
 
Dec 9, 2019 23:19:13   #
JimCT Loc: Connecticut
 
Sure as heck would. But then Judges in CT usually throw the cases out but at least inconvenienced the guilty.

Reply
Dec 9, 2019 23:32:09   #
BILLBYRD1 Loc: Prattville Al
 
Yes.

Reply
Dec 10, 2019 00:20:18   #
Scorchy Loc: Stonyford, ca.
 
Pls. do not let it get so out of hand as it has in Stupidafornia. I collected over 50 water bottles with heavy line many hooks and heavy weights at the bottom. In one year at our small lake. These people know it is wrong in our state to use a trot line. but our justice system when they are caught says oh it is that it is a cultural thing they don't know it is wrong and let them go. Over and over again.
We had a lady come to the store one morning and ask where the fish canning plant was? what??? I said with my friend. She said yes at dawn a big boat was hauling in a purse net and putting Hugh amounts of fish in smaller boats.
We do not have enough officers to be close to bust them, and on the rare times they do get them it is thrown out of court. I have seen this these people on you-tube, they have that kind of attitude.
Our lake not that long ago had largemouth bass to 15 lbs. 8 to 10 lbs. not that unusual. After years of netting the big females in the shallows, snaging them and having a boat with 6 people counting the kids. That is ten plus rods all with live bait well we have very few fish to 6 or 7 lbs. The Crappie was the best, 2 to 3lbs. in the fall and the numbers off the charts. This year I caught a few.
Do the right thing, say that's not right, then call authorities but be careful I have had my life threatened.

Reply
Dec 10, 2019 05:39:43   #
BobbyJ Loc: Texas
 
No. I would only inform the person tha “I think” violated the law, and leave it at that. The “violator “ will eventually be caught if the law enforcement officials are doing their job. Period.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 4 of 6 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
FishingStage.com - Forum
Copyright 2018-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.