Toss up but I like to catch crappie because of potential for bigger ones. All 3 species are fun to catch but hard to fillet compared to my favorite, which is walleye. Yumm🤪
Yellow perch taste like walleye but smaller.
Wv mike wrote:
What ones are the best eating. Unscramble this and head north to harvest one. ROICUAB
I vote for the Crappie Mike. I’ve never seen a Caribou before.
Hack 🇺🇸🍺🍺
ote=Wv mike]What ones are the best eating. Unscramble this and head north to harvest one. ROICUAB[/quote]
Lake Erie perch is the best you'll ever eat. I love perch, although bluegill are a top runner...🙂
Huntm22
Loc: Northern Utah. - West Haven
fishrmans wrote:
For me bluegill are hard to beat Then perch and last crappie. I wouldn’t pass up a good meal of any of them though.
I agree with your selection. But caribou is tasty also!
asking which of those three is best is just wrong. If you were 21 years old again & someone ask you which would you rather date, Lynda Carter, Ann Margaret or Barbara Eden. What's the difference except hair color? Same as those 3 fish, the're all 3 a prize on the table. I'll take a helping of whichever fish is golden brown first. I did not date any of those women.
Huntm22
Loc: Northern Utah. - West Haven
bottomcoon wrote:
asking which of those three is best is just wrong. If you were 21 years old again & someone ask you which would you rather date, Lynda Carter, Ann Margaret or Barbara Eden. What's the difference except hair color? Same as those 3 fish, the're all 3 a prize on the table. I'll take a helping of whichever fish is golden brown first. I did not date any of those women.
But you were thinking and thats a plus!😂
i think i would have to say the bluegill
They are all good but it's got to be Perch. I've never hunted CARIBOU. 👍
Wv mike wrote:
What ones are the best eating. Unscramble this and head north to harvest one. ROICUAB
To me, the yellow perch are the best of the three ! Still waitin' on
a chance to taste their bigger, tastier cousin, Mr. Walleye ! With winter comin' in up in the north country, I may have to wait 'til spring to catch one, now !
Catfish hunter wrote:
I pick box number two but perch are pretty darn good too. Haven’t tried box number three. I’d eat any of them over caribou though. That stuff is really dry and not real tasty in my opinion.
Never had a chance at eatin' caribou, but I HAVE had venison, elk, and moose; of those three,
I found the moose to be the
tastiest and most tender !
I’ve had moose and it was really good
Wv mike wrote:
I’ve had moose and it was really good
I had big horned sheep didn’t care for it. Never had caribou
Wv mike wrote:
I had big horned sheep didn’t care for it. Never had caribou
Not a fan of mutton (from adult sheep ?), but my dad used to grill
a 'leg of lamb' on a spit that was
to die for ! In the military, his rank was Steward 1st Class (he was
an Officers' cook), and he was a true grillmaster ! Last time was back in the late-70s/early-80s,
and haven't had anything nearly that good since then ! The
closest I've found was a local Greek restaurant back home, and even it was short of the mark in comparison !
He also had a marinade recipe
for prepping and cooking
'country-style' pork ribs the
scent of which would make
your mouth water and attract
all the neighbors any time he would cook them ! Can't even count the number of people
who bugged him for that
recipe ! Although I have a
copy of it, I can't even come
close to duplicating his results !
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.