fast_randy Loc: Blackfoot, Idaho

That's what I was thinking. I love to eat chicken gizzards and hearts. I have never tried them for cat fishing.

Chill55 Loc: Pleasant hill California

I fish the delta around Antioch or Brentwood calif really good cat fishing and we use stinky clams they stay on pretty good and when I take the grandkids out three boys I hardly have time to fish getting the fish off and shelling the clams for the boys clams there great

April0420 Loc: Hardinsburg KY

I use the tiny rubber bands ..once the liver or gizzard is on my hook I wrap the rubber band around it..u get 1000 of them for $1 at most dollar general stores..my opinion beats the heck out of trying to get the nylon off the barbs of the hook..happy fishing

threeCs Loc: Allen Texas

UPDATE 7/15/2020

I posted this awhile back and looked at suggestions and appreciate the inputs. I never did get around to using sponges instead of tubes.

I don't know if you would call this a dip or punch mixture. Seems to thick for dip and to thin for punch. It does separate easily and has to be stirred often in warm weather.

I took a portion and mixed cornmeal into so it became a dough bait. Tends to be easily crumbled with just cornmeal.

I took another portion and mixed equal parts of cornmeal and flour. This made a nice dough bait. Has good body.

I places both portions in water for water test. The cornmeal one held up better than I expected. The cornmeal/flour held up better. Both seem to would stay on the hook when using but have not tried them when actually fishing.

I am going to mix the remaining portion with the cornmeal and flour combination. I will add some drained minced garlic to the mixture. Garlic is always good, RIGHT.

If fish will take it I may purchase this product again, time will tell. I will post again after having a chance to fish with it.

The product in its original form did not work for me.