Fishing Stage - Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
Three cheers for smelt!
Michigan Fishing
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
Feb 28, 2023 08:43:17   #
Ryp Hankins Loc: N Michigan
 
Good job on a successful night! When we were kids in the ‘60s and ‘70s, if someone would suggest catching them hook and line I’m sure there would have been a sarcastic reply. Dipping was a blast but sitting outside with scissors cleaning a big bucket full was work. My dad and I would smoke them in applewood for a family treat.

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 09:04:46   #
Cougar Loc: Tennessee/Michigan
 
fishyaker wrote:
If you ever have an opportunity to go ice fishing for smelt...at night...I would strongly encourage you to take in the adventure!

Spent about 5 hours last night sitting in a shanty over 45' of water in hopes of scrounging up enough hook and line caught smelt to make for a couple of deep fried meals. Got set up just as the sun went down, and stayed until just after midnight. Going after smelt at night is new to me...so this was a first time effort.

Haley jigs, tipped with small maggots, seems to be the preferred choice of tackle on this pursuit. I was using a 28" long standard ice fishing rod in a medium action, which made detecting a bite somewhat difficult. It was like closing your eyes, holding out an ostrich feather quill, and then trying to feel a common housefly land on the end of it. Very, very subtle! I missed a lot of bites, but did manage to catch 28 smelt...all in the 5" to 7" length range.

Everything is a keeper, and I felt like a giddy child every time I got a solid hook up and brought a wriggling fish up thru the hole. Back in the 60's, we used to dip net these rascals when they were more common and ran up into almost every Great Lakes river tributary to spawn. We even caught them in small ditches...and always well after dark. It was an annual fishing ritual for us kids. Lot's of excitement and hoopla, as well as having had permission to stay out late with our friends.

Fishing last night was an absolute blast, and by the time I had decided to call it quits I noticed I was sitting in a half inch deep water pool on the floor of the shanty as the internal ice surface melted from my ever glowing space heater. There was some lake water in the mix as well due to the recent heavy snowfall that was pressing down a little bit on the 8" thick ice surface so that water could weep in from the slight depressions around the borings.

Thank goodness for the heat! It was 20 degrees when I started, and 13 when I finished. After having spent 5 hours inside the shanty it was a rude awakening to step outside and start the take down process. The edge flaps of the shanty fabric had frozen to the ice and it was like pulling 9" wide industrial strength Velcro strips off!

Got home, cleaned fish and laid my head on the pillow by 1:30 am. Dreampt all night long, or so it seemed, that I was encapsulated in a "green room" jigging up smelt one after another. If I count all the fish I caught while sleeping my tally may have been closer to a hundred!
If you ever have an opportunity to go ice fishing ... (show quote)


Very good memory’s of Smelt dipping in Michigan when we were “Young”. You’re right….buckets of Smelt caught in a short period of time!! Those were the days!!!

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 09:36:49   #
fishyaker Loc: NW Michigan (Lower Peninsula)
 
Ryp Hankins wrote:
Good job on a successful night! When we were kids in the ‘60s and ‘70s, if someone would suggest catching them hook and line I’m sure there would have been a sarcastic reply. Dipping was a blast but sitting outside with scissors cleaning a big bucket full was work. My dad and I would smoke them in applewood for a family treat.


Thank you Ryp! It's funny...when I caught my first one the other night, I actually laughed out loud about it! Like yourself, after dip netting them by the bucketfulls as a kid I never in my wildest dreams ever thought that someday I would be going after them one at a time...and with hook and line!

I had so much fun that I plan to go back now and then while we still have good ice.

Interesting about smoking them...never thought of that. Back in the day, when you have hundreds of them to clean...it was indeed a bit of a chore!

Reply
 
 
Feb 28, 2023 09:39:39   #
fishyaker Loc: NW Michigan (Lower Peninsula)
 
Cougar wrote:
Very good memory’s of Smelt dipping in Michigan when we were “Young”. You’re right….buckets of Smelt caught in a short period of time!! Those were the days!!!


Glad that you enjoyed the memory too. I have known about night fishing for smelt for many years, but just never had the gumption to give it a try. I wish I had included it on my annual agenda much sooner!

I think you can also catch them during the warm months, but going thru the ice seems to be most popular.

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 09:51:54   #
Cougar Loc: Tennessee/Michigan
 
fishyaker wrote:
Glad that you enjoyed the memory too. I have known about night fishing for smelt for many years, but just never had the gumption to give it a try. I wish I had included it on my annual agenda much sooner!

I think you can also catch them during the warm months, but going thru the ice seems to be most popular.


Before it was illegal to use them in Canada we would bring them up to Dryden area and catch monster pike with the smelt. That was in the early 70s…..lifetime ago!!! Pike loved those little guys!!!

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 11:44:03   #
fishyaker Loc: NW Michigan (Lower Peninsula)
 
Cougar wrote:
Before it was illegal to use them in Canada we would bring them up to Dryden area and catch monster pike with the smelt. That was in the early 70s…..lifetime ago!!! Pike loved those little guys!!!


I'll bet those pike thought they were in heaven. I can just picture it...a Johnson silver minnow or daredevle with a smelt trailing...the set up for a smash and grab from a submerged torpedo with the fin motors running full tilt!

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 11:48:30   #
bapabear Loc: Blaine, Washington
 
fishyaker wrote:
Thank you Ryp! It's funny...when I caught my first one the other night, I actually laughed out loud about it! Like yourself, after dip netting them by the bucketfulls as a kid I never in my wildest dreams ever thought that someday I would be going after them one at a time...and with hook and line!

I had so much fun that I plan to go back now and then while we still have good ice.

Interesting about smoking them...never thought of that. Back in the day, when you have hundreds of them to clean...it was indeed a bit of a chore!
Thank you Ryp! It's funny...when I caught my first... (show quote)


Just curious. Most people clean them here with a scissors rather than a knife. Is that how you do it there?

Reply
 
 
Feb 28, 2023 11:50:39   #
Cougar Loc: Tennessee/Michigan
 
fishyaker wrote:
I'll bet those pike thought they were in heaven. I can just picture it...a Johnson silver minnow or daredevle with a smelt trailing...the set up for a smash and grab from a submerged torpedo with the fin motors running full tilt!

We did exactly what you described and also anchored in a river and floated it down the river off the bottom full of Trimble hooks. It was in late May after the spawn, and those big females would eat anything!!! We would catch 40 inch pike with an 18 inch Blacktail sucker in its guts and it was trying to swallow a 12 inch smelt!! They were just gorging them selves on anything they could find….what a blast !!! Enjoy your smelt dinner.

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 12:00:26   #
woodguru Loc: El Dorado Ca
 
fishyaker wrote:
If you ever have an opportunity to go ice fishing for smelt...at night...I would strongly encourage you to take in the adventure!

Spent about 5 hours last night sitting in a shanty over 45' of water in hopes of scrounging up enough hook and line caught smelt to make for a couple of deep fried meals. Got set up just as the sun went down, and stayed until just after midnight. Going after smelt at night is new to me...so this was a first time effort.

Haley jigs, tipped with small maggots, seems to be the preferred choice of tackle on this pursuit. I was using a 28" long standard ice fishing rod in a medium action, which made detecting a bite somewhat difficult. It was like closing your eyes, holding out an ostrich feather quill, and then trying to feel a common housefly land on the end of it. Very, very subtle! I missed a lot of bites, but did manage to catch 28 smelt...all in the 5" to 7" length range.

Everything is a keeper, and I felt like a giddy child every time I got a solid hook up and brought a wriggling fish up thru the hole. Back in the 60's, we used to dip net these rascals when they were more common and ran up into almost every Great Lakes river tributary to spawn. We even caught them in small ditches...and always well after dark. It was an annual fishing ritual for us kids. Lot's of excitement and hoopla, as well as having had permission to stay out late with our friends.

Fishing last night was an absolute blast, and by the time I had decided to call it quits I noticed I was sitting in a half inch deep water pool on the floor of the shanty as the internal ice surface melted from my ever glowing space heater. There was some lake water in the mix as well due to the recent heavy snowfall that was pressing down a little bit on the 8" thick ice surface so that water could weep in from the slight depressions around the borings.

Thank goodness for the heat! It was 20 degrees when I started, and 13 when I finished. After having spent 5 hours inside the shanty it was a rude awakening to step outside and start the take down process. The edge flaps of the shanty fabric had frozen to the ice and it was like pulling 9" wide industrial strength Velcro strips off!

Got home, cleaned fish and laid my head on the pillow by 1:30 am. Dreampt all night long, or so it seemed, that I was encapsulated in a "green room" jigging up smelt one after another. If I count all the fish I caught while sleeping my tally may have been closer to a hundred!
If you ever have an opportunity to go ice fishing ... (show quote)

Growing up as a kid my grandmother owned one of the beach houses on Martin's beach, which was a private beach, we'd have big Smelt fries with the family where we caught upwards of 200 pounds of Smelt with nets. Martin's was one of the better beaches for runs of Smelt.

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 12:03:18   #
woodguru Loc: El Dorado Ca
 
Cougar wrote:
Very good memory’s of Smelt dipping in Michigan when we were “Young”. You’re right….buckets of Smelt caught in a short period of time!! Those were the days!!!


I have to laugh...gee, what do you think happened to all those Smelt? Lol

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 12:19:37   #
fishyaker Loc: NW Michigan (Lower Peninsula)
 
bapabear wrote:
Just curious. Most people clean them here with a scissors rather than a knife. Is that how you do it there?


bapabear...I used a knife, but scissors work well too. I suppose my approach adds a fractional amount of extra time per fish though...so if I was doing a massive catch...like when we were kids...the scissors would be the ticket!

Reply
 
 
Feb 28, 2023 12:20:56   #
fishyaker Loc: NW Michigan (Lower Peninsula)
 
Cougar wrote:
We did exactly what you described and also anchored in a river and floated it down the river off the bottom full of Trimble hooks. It was in late May after the spawn, and those big females would eat anything!!! We would catch 40 inch pike with an 18 inch Blacktail sucker in its guts and it was trying to swallow a 12 inch smelt!! They were just gorging them selves on anything they could find….what a blast !!! Enjoy your smelt dinner.


Very cool Cougar! The smelt dinner was scrumptious. It's been a while since I had them fresh caught, and I forgot just how tasty they are!

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 12:22:56   #
fishyaker Loc: NW Michigan (Lower Peninsula)
 
woodguru wrote:
Growing up as a kid my grandmother owned one of the beach houses on Martin's beach, which was a private beach, we'd have big Smelt fries with the family where we caught upwards of 200 pounds of Smelt with nets. Martin's was one of the better beaches for runs of Smelt.


WOW...now that's a lot of smelt! Our runs back in the day were heavy...but nothing like that! We typically stopped dipping our steel mesh cone shaped nets once we had a 5 gallon pail full. For fresh eating, that was all we could consume over the next 2 or 3 days!

Thanks for sharing your story...do you still go after them nowadays?

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 14:10:15   #
Ryp Hankins Loc: N Michigan
 
bapabear wrote:
Just curious. Most people clean them here with a scissors rather than a knife. Is that how you do it there?


Yes we used scissors, at least some 50 years ago.

Reply
Feb 28, 2023 15:38:19   #
Fishing Fool Loc: redding, ca
 
Several years ago my buddy and I went to the Northere California coast for smelt and when they were rolling in the incoming waves we would stick a 5 foot triangular dip net for them. We filled 7 or 8 5 gallon buckets with one dip and it took tow of us to drag it onto the beach. We cleaned smelt for a good 3 hours but they were so good dipped in corn meal and fried. Also made great bait for the ling cod we caught later.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
FishingStage.com - Forum
Copyright 2018-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.