Fishing Stage - Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
2023 Fishing Resolution
California Fishing
Page <prev 2 of 5 next> last>>
Jan 1, 2023 14:34:27   #
Fredfish Loc: Prospect CT.
 
NoCal Steve wrote:
Fred... that is perfect fish handling advice!


Thanks Steve, just trying to do my part.

Reply
Jan 1, 2023 14:43:56   #
Supersport Loc: Florida's First Coast much love hlr
 
NoCal Steve wrote:
We've read many Catch and Release debates here on the Stage and it made me think about my methods. I've gone deeper into this subject reading studies and statistical analysis of mortality rates. One controversial study concludes the mortality rate caused by tournaments is 40%. No doubt that study contributed to some of the changes in format we've seen lately. But, the data that is generally accepted and used comes from a metastudy (I think that was the name). A metastudy looks at all the studies that have been done to mine data. The mortality rate for largemouth bass from catch and release is between 18 and 19%. For every 100 bass released almost 20 will die! For Striped bass it is less than 6%. For trout, more than 20%. The duration and difficulty of the fight, time out of the water, and handling of the fish are identified as the biggest contributors to mortality.
All of this information is to help you understand why I decided 2023 is going to have a New Year's resolution to reduce my catch and release mortality rate. Here is a list of the things I am doing towards that goal.
1. 90% of my fishing is catch and release. The two live wells on my boat will be converted to storage compartments. One live well will be available to use for those times one is needed.
2. Experiment with barbless hooks to determine if using them 100% is possible.
3. Fish smaller than 2 lbs, every effort will be made to release it without removing the fish from the water. Small fish have less oxygenated blood and can get beat up pretty bad during the fight.
4. Fish brought on board will be secure in a net to prevent getting lose and flopping around the boat. Camera, pliers and anything else will be out and ready to use. I will touch the fish as little as possible, take pictures, and remove baits, quickly. Then. return the fish to the water as fast as I can. Allow the fish to recover inside the landing net in the water as needed.
Here is my thing...if I practice catch and release it just doesn't make sense for me to not do everything I can for my fish to survive. I want to do better than 18%. I hope that many of you will read this and decide to adopt my 2023 resolution to reduce your catch and release mortality rate.
We've read many Catch and Release debates here on ... (show quote)


NoCal Steve sounds like a great ideal I was taught catch and eat problem solved tight lines supersport

Reply
Jan 2, 2023 01:17:50   #
NoCal Steve Loc: Dunnigan, CA
 
Supersport wrote:
NoCal Steve sounds like a great ideal I was taught catch and eat problem solved tight lines supersport


Nothing wrong with that SS... I staunchly defend anyone's right to keep a legal limit caught by legal means.

Reply
 
 
Jan 2, 2023 09:15:46   #
MoJoe Loc: Springfield, MO
 
I try to wet my hand before handling fish, especially trout.

Reply
Jan 2, 2023 09:54:41   #
nutz4fish Loc: Colchester, CT
 
Grizzly 17 wrote:
I could never figure out the hook could dead center those little strings 🤣


🔎❓🤔.

Reply
Jan 2, 2023 12:18:41   #
bapabear Loc: Blaine, Washington
 
It all sounds good to me. I wish tournament folks would get penalized for mistreating released fish. I am a reel supporter of the catch, weigh and release tournaments. But they still flip the small most vulnerable fish back in. It would be easy to make a rule that required all fish to be released in the water.

Reply
Jan 2, 2023 14:13:53   #
Fishing Fool Loc: redding, ca
 
Why do you need to take pictures.....just release them all in the water and why need a net when they are released?

Reply
 
 
Jan 2, 2023 14:27:57   #
Ontothenextfish Loc: Colorado
 
NoCal Steve wrote:
We've read many Catch and Release debates here on the Stage and it made me think about my methods. I've gone deeper into this subject reading studies and statistical analysis of mortality rates. One controversial study concludes the mortality rate caused by tournaments is 40%. No doubt that study contributed to some of the changes in format we've seen lately. But, the data that is generally accepted and used comes from a metastudy (I think that was the name). A metastudy looks at all the studies that have been done to mine data. The mortality rate for largemouth bass from catch and release is between 18 and 19%. For every 100 bass released almost 20 will die! For Striped bass it is less than 6%. For trout, more than 20%. The duration and difficulty of the fight, time out of the water, and handling of the fish are identified as the biggest contributors to mortality.
All of this information is to help you understand why I decided 2023 is going to have a New Year's resolution to reduce my catch and release mortality rate. Here is a list of the things I am doing towards that goal.
1. 90% of my fishing is catch and release. The two live wells on my boat will be converted to storage compartments. One live well will be available to use for those times one is needed.
2. Experiment with barbless hooks to determine if using them 100% is possible.
3. Fish smaller than 2 lbs, every effort will be made to release it without removing the fish from the water. Small fish have less oxygenated blood and can get beat up pretty bad during the fight.
4. Fish brought on board will be secure in a net to prevent getting lose and flopping around the boat. Camera, pliers and anything else will be out and ready to use. I will touch the fish as little as possible, take pictures, and remove baits, quickly. Then. return the fish to the water as fast as I can. Allow the fish to recover inside the landing net in the water as needed.
Here is my thing...if I practice catch and release it just doesn't make sense for me to not do everything I can for my fish to survive. I want to do better than 18%. I hope that many of you will read this and decide to adopt my 2023 resolution to reduce your catch and release mortality rate.
We've read many Catch and Release debates here on ... (show quote)

You know a lot of people would say just stop fishing if you feel bad about hurting fish. How would you feel if something was smarter than a human and decided fishing for people was fun. I’d sure hope they didn’t use big hooks with barbs if they were able to trick me into biting! Put a pizza on a hook and you got me, glad I’m not a fish ! Using light line sometimes results in my hook and senko becoming fish lip jewelry, I hate that! It seems us humans just can’t leave stuff be, we gotta mess with something. I love messing with the fish, I can’t stop! People going to be people, some will shoot a fish with a bow and arrow with satisfaction. Others will handle the fish with gloves and rags to not hurt the fish with the same satisfaction! The key is being ok with your decisions and yourself! I used to feed the bass a minnow I’d keep in a pail of water after tricking them with my senko, it made me feel better about ripping their little lips apart. Ok I never did that but I am as careful as I can be with the fish I decide to trick. Thanks for being careful with the fish, Fish lives Matter!🤣🤔😳✌️🐠

Reply
Jan 2, 2023 14:50:39   #
NoCal Steve Loc: Dunnigan, CA
 
Fishing Fool wrote:
Why do you need to take pictures.....just release them all in the water and why need a net when they are released?


Well, personally I have several reasons. One is lure selection such as a jerkbait will often sink all three treble hooks into the fish. A flat bottom rubber net helps me to remove the hooks quickly and avoid getting stuck myself. Another reason is that I like to weigh my fish, save it to memory and get a total for my best five. This year I'm not going to weigh my smaller keepers at approx 2 lbs. And finally, I like to take pictures. Last year I stopped taking pics of myself, for the most part, with fish 3lbs or less. This year I'm going to try 4lbs but, there are circumstances that happen where I want pics regardless of size. That will be my choice to make and I will be ready for the responsibilities that go with the choice. This applies to bass fishing which is what I do the most. If I'm trout fishing I'll do everything I can to not remove it from the water. Striper fishing gives me a greater margin for error as they are very resilient and have a high catch and release survival rate.

Reply
Jan 2, 2023 15:03:59   #
NoCal Steve Loc: Dunnigan, CA
 
Ontothenextfish wrote:
You know a lot of people would say just stop fishing if you feel bad about hurting fish. How would you feel if something was smarter than a human and decided fishing for people was fun. I’d sure hope they didn’t use big hooks with barbs if they were able to trick me into biting! Put a pizza on a hook and you got me, glad I’m not a fish ! Using light line sometimes results in my hook and senko becoming fish lip jewelry, I hate that! It seems us humans just can’t leave stuff be, we gotta mess with something. I love messing with the fish, I can’t stop! People going to be people, some will shoot a fish with a bow and arrow with satisfaction. Others will handle the fish with gloves and rags to not hurt the fish with the same satisfaction! The key is being ok with your decisions and yourself! I used to feed the bass a minnow I’d keep in a pail of water after tricking them with my senko, it made me feel better about ripping their little lips apart. Ok I never did that but I am as careful as I can be with the fish I decide to trick. Thanks for being careful with the fish, Fish lives Matter!🤣🤔😳✌️🐠
You know a lot of people would say just stop fishi... (show quote)


I knew this was going to come up and just so happens to have been part of my research. This has nothing to with causing the fish pain. Get that out of your head. In fact, fish do not feel pain the same way we do. Sticking yourself with a hook is not what a fish feels with their primitive nervous system. This is about returning the fish in a condition that it will survive. This is about being a good steward of a resource through sustainment. Hatching a bunch of eggs to replenish fish populations works but sustainment will always be the best possible method. Hopefully this is a good explanation that makes sense to most everyone.

Reply
Jan 2, 2023 15:19:22   #
hacksaw Loc: Pasadena, Texas
 
NoCal Steve wrote:
We've read many Catch and Release debates here on the Stage and it made me think about my methods. I've gone deeper into this subject reading studies and statistical analysis of mortality rates. One controversial study concludes the mortality rate caused by tournaments is 40%. No doubt that study contributed to some of the changes in format we've seen lately. But, the data that is generally accepted and used comes from a metastudy (I think that was the name). A metastudy looks at all the studies that have been done to mine data. The mortality rate for largemouth bass from catch and release is between 18 and 19%. For every 100 bass released almost 20 will die! For Striped bass it is less than 6%. For trout, more than 20%. The duration and difficulty of the fight, time out of the water, and handling of the fish are identified as the biggest contributors to mortality.
All of this information is to help you understand why I decided 2023 is going to have a New Year's resolution to reduce my catch and release mortality rate. Here is a list of the things I am doing towards that goal.
1. 90% of my fishing is catch and release. The two live wells on my boat will be converted to storage compartments. One live well will be available to use for those times one is needed.
2. Experiment with barbless hooks to determine if using them 100% is possible.
3. Fish smaller than 2 lbs, every effort will be made to release it without removing the fish from the water. Small fish have less oxygenated blood and can get beat up pretty bad during the fight.
4. Fish brought on board will be secure in a net to prevent getting lose and flopping around the boat. Camera, pliers and anything else will be out and ready to use. I will touch the fish as little as possible, take pictures, and remove baits, quickly. Then. return the fish to the water as fast as I can. Allow the fish to recover inside the landing net in the water as needed.
Here is my thing...if I practice catch and release it just doesn't make sense for me to not do everything I can for my fish to survive. I want to do better than 18%. I hope that many of you will read this and decide to adopt my 2023 resolution to reduce your catch and release mortality rate.
We've read many Catch and Release debates here on ... (show quote)


Thanks for the good information Steve. I will be more easy on the fish I put back in the water. I already use a rubbery net but will follow your lead on other suggestions.
Hack 🇺🇸🍺🍺

Reply
 
 
Jan 2, 2023 16:30:26   #
NoCal Steve Loc: Dunnigan, CA
 
hacksaw wrote:
Thanks for the good information Steve. I will be more easy on the fish I put back in the water. I already use a rubbery net but will follow your lead on other suggestions.
Hack 🇺🇸🍺🍺


Thanks Hack... Happy New Year! May 2023 bless you with a trip to Lake Houston and an ice chest full of Crappie!

Reply
Jan 2, 2023 17:11:31   #
Deltaexpress Loc: Galt, CA
 
Right on NorCal Steve. I have had a bass boat of some sort for a long time and have never kept one. Matter a fact I can not remember the last time I kept a striper, salmon or steelhead. Use only barbless hooks and if I bring a fish on board it’s to weigh it and snap a quick picture. Catch and release so you can catch them again. Good luck and tight lines.

Reply
Jan 2, 2023 22:03:49   #
bapabear Loc: Blaine, Washington
 
NoCal Steve wrote:
I knew this was going to come up and just so happens to have been part of my research. This has nothing to with causing the fish pain. Get that out of your head. In fact, fish do not feel pain the same way we do. Sticking yourself with a hook is not what a fish feels with their primitive nervous system. This is about returning the fish in a condition that it will survive. This is about being a good steward of a resource through sustainment. Hatching a bunch of eggs to replenish fish populations works but sustainment will always be the best possible method. Hopefully this is a good explanation that makes sense to most everyone.
I knew this was going to come up and just so happe... (show quote)


It makes good sense to me.

Reply
Jan 3, 2023 00:03:14   #
Jim Kay Loc: Franklin, Virginia
 
NoCal Steve wrote:
We've read many Catch and Release debates here on the Stage and it made me think about my methods. I've gone deeper into this subject reading studies and statistical analysis of mortality rates. One controversial study concludes the mortality rate caused by tournaments is 40%. No doubt that study contributed to some of the changes in format we've seen lately. But, the data that is generally accepted and used comes from a metastudy (I think that was the name). A metastudy looks at all the studies that have been done to mine data. The mortality rate for largemouth bass from catch and release is between 18 and 19%. For every 100 bass released almost 20 will die! For Striped bass it is less than 6%. For trout, more than 20%. The duration and difficulty of the fight, time out of the water, and handling of the fish are identified as the biggest contributors to mortality.
All of this information is to help you understand why I decided 2023 is going to have a New Year's resolution to reduce my catch and release mortality rate. Here is a list of the things I am doing towards that goal.
1. 90% of my fishing is catch and release. The two live wells on my boat will be converted to storage compartments. One live well will be available to use for those times one is needed.
2. Experiment with barbless hooks to determine if using them 100% is possible.
3. Fish smaller than 2 lbs, every effort will be made to release it without removing the fish from the water. Small fish have less oxygenated blood and can get beat up pretty bad during the fight.
4. Fish brought on board will be secure in a net to prevent getting lose and flopping around the boat. Camera, pliers and anything else will be out and ready to use. I will touch the fish as little as possible, take pictures, and remove baits, quickly. Then. return the fish to the water as fast as I can. Allow the fish to recover inside the landing net in the water as needed.
Here is my thing...if I practice catch and release it just doesn't make sense for me to not do everything I can for my fish to survive. I want to do better than 18%. I hope that many of you will read this and decide to adopt my 2023 resolution to reduce your catch and release mortality rate.
We've read many Catch and Release debates here on ... (show quote)


That is what I have been doing all of my fishing years.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 5 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
FishingStage.com - Forum
Copyright 2018-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.