Fishing Stage - Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main
PFD Automatic or Manual?
Maryland Fishing
Page 1 of 2 next>
Jul 23, 2023 10:16:29   #
plumbob Loc: New Windsor Maryland
 
How do you have your PFD set up?

Automatic deployment or Manual?

And Why?

Personally I went Automatic in the event I have a physical problem with going manual.

Reply
Jul 23, 2023 10:43:33   #
ripogenu Loc: norfolk, MA
 
plumbob wrote:
How do you have your PFD set up?

Automatic deployment or Manual?

And Why?

Personally I went Automatic in the event I have a physical problem with going manual.


Automatic. if you get knocked out or go into shock from the cold water manual ain't gonna help.

Reply
Jul 23, 2023 10:57:00   #
fishyaker Loc: NW Michigan (Lower Peninsula)
 
I tend to wear a conventional PDF about 95% of the time with no CO2 cartridge. It is more comfortable when sitting down low in a sea kayak and adds some back support to the low profile cockpit combing rim. So...of course no deployment needed on that style...

That being said, I do have a slim CO2 styled alternate version that is less bulky for when I am out in my Pescador Pilot 120 pedal kayak, or a smaller, shorter sea kayak that I use when on camping trips.

My unit does not have the "auto" feature. It must be deployed via the pull cord gripper, or manually inflated by the user via the air tube filler. I feel comfortable with it but understand what can happen in a capsize, especially if you are hit by a speeding boat and not a slow motion roll over.

This thread reminds me that it is time to change out the CO2 cartridge and put a fresh one in. The last time I made the change my daughter was with me and just for kicks I had her put it on and pull the cord to see if the unit was still OK. It "was", and we both had a good laugh as she bloated up while standing in the garage!

Good post Plumb...kind of gets me to thinking about investing in a more modern CO2 PDF that does have the auto mode.

Reply
 
 
Jul 23, 2023 11:23:05   #
plumbob Loc: New Windsor Maryland
 
fishyaker wrote:
I tend to wear a conventional PDF about 95% of the time with no CO2 cartridge. It is more comfortable when sitting down low in a sea kayak and adds some back support to the low profile cockpit combing rim. So...of course no deployment needed on that style...

That being said, I do have a slim CO2 styled alternate version that is less bulky for when I am out in my Pescador Pilot 120 pedal kayak, or a smaller, shorter sea kayak that I use when on camping trips.

My unit does not have the "auto" feature. It must be deployed via the pull cord gripper, or manually inflated by the user via the air tube filler. I feel comfortable with it but understand what can happen in a capsize, especially if you are hit by a speeding boat and not a slow motion roll over.

This thread reminds me that it is time to change out the CO2 cartridge and put a fresh one in. The last time I made the change my daughter was with me and just for kicks I had her put it on and pull the cord to see if the unit was still OK. It "was", and we both had a good laugh as she bloated up while standing in the garage!

Good post Plumb...kind of gets me to thinking about investing in a more modern CO2 PDF that does have the auto mode.
I tend to wear a conventional PDF about 95% of the... (show quote)


Thanks fy. Andy B's post of ending up in the water made me think of it. I just changed my 6 year old cartridge this past spring.

Reply
Jul 23, 2023 12:32:09   #
Fredfish Loc: Prospect CT.
 
plumbob wrote:
How do you have your PFD set up?

Automatic deployment or Manual?

And Why?

Personally I went Automatic in the event I have a physical problem with going manual.


This is the first year that I've worn any PFD on a regular basis. I went with an Auto/manual inflatable, after recent heart and COPD issues. Also getting knocked off my feet by a wakeboat last year, sealed the deal on the auto version. It's a pain to have to rearm them, but at least I'll be here to do so.

PS: The "Bobbin" that activates the auto function has an expiration date on it. If expired, it's no longer a legal PFD in the eyes of the USCG.

Reply
Jul 23, 2023 14:15:21   #
Jer Loc: N. Illinois 🇺🇸
 
plumbob wrote:
How do you have your PFD set up?

Automatic deployment or Manual?

And Why?

Personally I went Automatic in the event I have a physical problem with going manual.


I have mine setup in automatic mode mainly because I fish in cold weather and cold water. Numb fingers have trouble with fishing sometimes but I have hand warmers. Would not have any if I went into the water. Just not taking that bet anymore.

Reply
Jul 23, 2023 14:34:32   #
Randyhartford Loc: Lawrence, Kansas
 
plumbob wrote:
How do you have your PFD set up?

Automatic deployment or Manual?

And Why?

Personally I went Automatic in the event I have a physical problem with going manual.


Automatic, for the same reason, Bob.

Reply
 
 
Jul 23, 2023 18:02:10   #
Flytier Loc: Wilmington Delaware
 
I bought an automatic pfd last summer. Didn't need one standing on a beach, but In my Tracker it's a different story. Have a little problem with my balance these days so if I fall there's always a chance of whacking my head, so auto it is.

Reply
Jul 23, 2023 18:26:27   #
Grizzly 17 Loc: South central Pa
 
plumbob wrote:
How do you have your PFD set up?

Automatic deployment or Manual?

And Why?

Personally I went Automatic in the event I have a physical problem with going manual.


Auto/manual Bob.
After first winter fishing from a boat I came to a conclusion.
Insulated coveralls n a regular lifejacket wasn't working
Drop on the deck then try picking it up.
Couldn't bend over far enough.
Bought Auto late 90' 2 yrs ago I set it off getting it out of storage box.
Originally pill n cylinder it worked just fine 👍👍

Reply
Jul 24, 2023 07:39:28   #
plumbob Loc: New Windsor Maryland
 
Flytier wrote:
I bought an automatic pfd last summer. Didn't need one standing on a beach, but In my Tracker it's a different story. Have a little problem with my balance these days so if I fall there's always a chance of whacking my head, so auto it is.


Just don't get pulled into the surf by a big Marlin Jimmy.

Reply
Jul 24, 2023 08:29:37   #
MoJoe Loc: Springfield, MO
 
Auto/manual backup. For 50 years, kept the old style stowed so as to be legal, never used.
But now: I'm old, and want all the help I can get if I hit the water.

Reply
 
 
Jul 24, 2023 09:09:34   #
OldBassGuy Loc: Temecula, CA
 
ripogenu wrote:
Automatic. if you get knocked out or go into shock from the cold water manual ain't gonna help.


Ditto that

Reply
Jul 24, 2023 09:18:20   #
plumbob Loc: New Windsor Maryland
 
MoJoe wrote:
Auto/manual backup. For 50 years, kept the old style stowed so as to be legal, never used.
But now: I'm old, and want all the help I can get if I hit the water.


Speaking of backup, I just purchased a throw cushion for my kayak. Dual purpose though, got me 2" in height as i have it as a seat cushion too.

Reply
Jul 24, 2023 15:57:15   #
USAF Major Loc: Sea Bright, NJ
 
Mine is on automatic or I can't fish solo per a deal with spouse.

Reply
Jul 24, 2023 21:17:59   #
Uncle_T Loc: Georgia
 
I have manual pfds because I don’t want them going off if I get rained on or if I fall in and am ok I don’t want to pay the price for recharging unless I actually needed to use it, I’m rarely around anything I would hit my head on and if it’s that cold I’m not fishing

Reply
Page 1 of 2 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main
FishingStage.com - Forum
Copyright 2018-2024 IDF International Technologies, Inc.