If you absolutely had to choose: I’m sure many on this site are both avid hunters and fisherman, but I’m curious that if you had to choose between the two, what would it be and why. I...

bknecht Loc: Northeast pa

I’m sure many on this site are both avid hunters and fisherman, but I’m curious that if you had to choose between the two, what would it be and why. I always felt it an unfair question but in my older years have easily made my decision. Let’s hear yours.

charlykilo Loc: Garden Valley Ca

Same as yours. Nonchoice Can't walk to hunt.

Jeremy Loc: America

I love both. With a bum knee and being on disability...im leaning toward fishing. For more than one reason. Buddies got old that I hunted with. hunting locally has sucked more and more. I have quads and Jeeps but no fun by yourself. Elk is a group thing.

badbobby Loc: Humble Texas

Jeremy wrote:

I love both. With a bum knee and being on disability...im leaning toward fishing. For more than one reason. Buddies got old that I hunted with. hunting locally has sucked more and more. I have quads and Jeeps but no fun by yourself. Elk is a group thing.

gotta be fishin
it's too hard to hunt now
land owners either want a lotta money for a lease or the don't want you on their land
so I'll just go fishin

saw1 Loc: nor cal Windsor

Jeremy wrote:

I love both. With a bum knee and being on disability...im leaning toward fishing. For more than one reason. Buddies got old that I hunted with. hunting locally has sucked more and more. I have quads and Jeeps but no fun by yourself. Elk is a group thing.

Well livin in California, the choice would be easy, fishin. They got so many gun laws and restrictions that it's hard to go huntin here anymore. It's hard to even buy ammunition anymore.
NOW, if I still lived in Texas, IDK which I would choose. Probly would still be fishin cause I could do it year round and havin a boat really helps you to enjoy more opportunities.

bknecht Loc: Northeast pa

Saw, gotta agree on the ammo. Went to Cabelas the other day and they literally had NOTHING in the ammo department.

Robert J Samples Loc: Round Rock, Texas

As with most of the prior quotes, I can no longer walk far enought to hunt. I can fish if I can remain seated, so fishing by default. Just Sayin...RJS

Ben Bragg Loc: Dayton Ohio

Fishing for sure
Older I get the stamina required for hunting diminishes
It’s not easy fishing fighting waves either.
Used to live hunting.

saw1 Loc: nor cal Windsor

bknecht wrote:

Saw, gotta agree on the ammo. Went to Cabelas the other day and they literally had NOTHING in the ammo department.

Our Walmart doesn't even sell ammo anymore. I think that may even be nation wide.

plumbob Loc: New Windsor Maryland

I am leaning towards fishing. To many DICK Cheney's out there. Then again the victim was an attorney. LOL

Some may say justifiable. Again with the LOL

Jeremy Loc: America

Isn't the AMMO shortage from the same ol scare tactics every time there is a guy like what happens in 16 days? I know NOONE will be at my door for them but a bunch of folks are hypnotized that it is real. I never believe it nor will I. Ammo is short here too but it is temporary. I just don't believe things when they are as bogus as the source of info. Consider Source.

Gordon Loc: Charleston South Carolina

Fishing. Can do that year round. No season on most salt water fish.

Jeremy Loc: America

saw1 wrote:

Our Walmart doesn't even sell ammo anymore. I think that may even be nation wide.

They used to. I think some companies are trying to make a statement or don't want insurance etc...or it is after on site shootings

saw1 Loc: nor cal Windsor

Jeremy wrote:

Isn't the AMMO shortage from the same ol scare tactics every time there is a guy like what happens in 16 days? I know NOONE will be at my door for them but a bunch of folks are hypnotized that it is real. I never believe it nor will I. Ammo is short here too but it is temporary. I just don't believe things when they are as bogus as the source of info. Consider Source.

Ammo may be in short supply, but Walmart stopped carrying ammo awhile back. They don't sell it any more.

Egghead

This is an easy one !!!! I don't do either. I just go to work everyday and don't have to deside what to do.